Last month (8/13/15), Katie had to go to Charlottesville for work. I decided to go along figuring that I could go visit some or all of the three presidential homes in the area. As it turns out, I made it to Jefferson's and Monroe's, but will have to make another trip for Madison.
Monticello reminded me a lot of Mt. Vernon in size, scale and production. It is a huge property with a very polished visitors center and tour. There seemed to be hundreds of staff members keeping things running. As with Mt. Vernon, there's a 20 minute film that hits the high points of Jefferson's life and Monticello. I was hurrying to catch a tour, so I skipped it. There's a shuttle bus that takes you the short, uphill distance from the visitors center to the house. Granted, I was there midweek in August, but I felt as if I was the only person between the ages of 20 and 60. Most of the other guests needed the shuttle. I'd recommend that you take the bus up, but walk back.
I was really impressed with the ingenuity displayed throughout the home. The tour guide pointed out the weather vane that was built down through the ceiling so that TJ could check the weather direction from the comfort of his home. He also pointed out the indoor shutters that folded into the wall and the double doors that operate as one using a chain below the floor. In the bedroom is the contraption that TJ built to replicate letters as he wrote them. He tinkered with everything to make it as efficient as possible.
The other thing that impressed me was the amount of original material that they have been able to reclaim. It was cool to see his bedroom, dining room, office and library relatively intact with original furniture, books and art work. Two other things that I thought were cool: 1) You could see UVA from his deck. That was not a coincidence. He chose the site so that he could monitor construction progress from his hilltop. Supposedly, if he didn't like what he saw, he would ride down there even at the age of 80. 2) The small cemetery where the family is buried. Descendants are still being buried there. It would be a pretty cool place to be laid to rest.
Ash Lawn is extremely modest in size and production compared to Monticello. It is now owned and operated by William & Mary. The house is relatively intact, but there is not as much original
material in the house. Their dining room table is original, which I
thought was cool to picture the family sitting around 200 years ago.
One of the first things that you learn on the tour is that Monroe is pictured in the famous painting of Washington crossing the Delaware River. However, we know that he was not in the boat with GW. Another thing that the docent pointed out was that the painting includes the US flag which did not exist at the time. Also, the passage took place at night and the painting depicts a daytime scene. I thought that was interesting and good facts to drop next time you see the painting.
If you're at Monticello, it's worth the trip 3 miles down the road, but probably not worth its own trip. I think I'm in the majority with that opinion. I think I heard that they get about 25,000 visitors a year, compared to the 400,000 that Monticello gets. When I arrived, there were only about 10 other cars in the parking lot, 4 of which must have been those of employees. I was only the second person for the tour, which eventually numbered about 7. The first woman to arrive lives in Chevy Chase, MD. It was quite a coincidence.
In my original TJ post, I mentioned Carter Mountain and said that I'd like to check it out. It turns out that there's a Carter Mountain Orchard just down the road from Monticello. I stopped by on my way and was very impressed. As luck would have it, every Thursday in the summer, they host a sunset party. So I left with the idea of heading back later that evening. We took a picnic dinner and I enjoyed some of the locally produced wine, hard cider and ice cream. They had live music and a huge crowd. I'm really glad we went and highly recommend it. It's a great view.
In sum, I think if you're in Charlottesville, you should go see Monticello. If you care at all about Monroe, then Ash Lawn is worth the quick visit. If you're there on a Thursday in the summer, go to Carter Mountain for the sunset.
4T3 and Counting...
A chronological reading of presidents' biographies.
Friday, October 2, 2015
Wednesday, September 30, 2015
5. James Monroe
5. James Monroe (In Office 3/4/1817 – 3/4/1825)
Book Title: James Monroe: The Quest for National Identity
Author: Harry Ammon
Published:1971
Length: 706
Start Date: 2/25/15
End Date: 8/1/15So the write up took only 2 month. Anyway, 5 down.
Most Notable:
- He entered William & Mary at 16, but spent only 2 years there before enlisting to fight in the Revolutionary War. After the war, Monroe decided that he wanted to get into politics. His friend and mentor, Thomas Jefferson suggested that he study the law and become a lawyer in order to further his political career. As such, Monroe studied law under TJ, then the governor of Virginia.
- While fighting in the war, he was nearly killed. He was shot in the shoulder, severing an artery that a local doctor was quickly able to seal. Otherwise, he likely would have bled out. He was nursed back to health for 3 months at a stranger's home nearby.
- He won his first election in 1782 when he was elected to the Virginia House of Delegates.
- In 1783, the Virginia state legislature nominated him to represent the state in Congress. He served for the next 3 years.
- When the Constitution was being circulated for ratification, Monroe argued strenuously against the electoral college. He thought it violated the most basic concept of a republican government (1 person, 1 vote). He also thought it would render the President subservient to state interests. I wish people had listened to him. The electoral college makes no sense.
- Madison and Monroe were very close. Yet in 1788 Monroe decided to run against Madison for Congress. It was a very congenial campaign on both sides. Madison cruised to victory and the two resumed their friendship without injury.
- In 1790, at the age of just 32, Monroe was elected to the Senate.
- In 1794, President Washington appointed Monroe Minister to France. Monroe left the Senate for Europe, but was recalled just 2 years later because Washington felt as though Monroe was letting partisanship impact his diplomacy.
- In 1799, Monroe was elected Governor of Virginia. At the time, the Governor was elected by the legislator every year. Monroe served the maximum 3 consecutive terms and earned $9,999 over those 3 years.
- In order to make up for 3 years of modest income, he planned to settle in Richmond and practice law following his third term. However, President Jefferson sent Monroe to France to negotiate the purchase of New Orleans, which eventually ended up being the Louisiana Purchase.
- He stayed in Europe as the Minister to the Court of St. James in London until 1807. While there, he tried to extend the Jay Treaty, which was set to expire 10 years after it was signed. Monroe thought it positioned the US well, but TJ and Secretary of State Madison, both Francophiles, refused to submit it to the Senate for approval. The failure to reach an agreement led in part to the War of 1812. Monroe was somewhat offended by the disagreement with his friends and their relationships were strained for a couple of years.
- In 1811 Monroe was again elected Governor of Virginia, but served only 4 months before President Madison appointed him Secretary of State.
- One thing that's changed over time is that Republicans were very against military spending. The author uses the term "anti-militaristic principles." The author notes that Republicans were horrified that $9 million of the $25.5 budget was spent on defense. That's hard to picture today. Monroe was more inline with current Republicans. He thought it was important to threaten military action in negotiations.
- At the beginning of the War of 1812, Madison appointed Monroe acting Secretary of War. He served there for only 10 weeks to organize the war efforts and then returned to the State Department. However, his replacement at the War Department left and Monroe then became the first person to hold 2 cabinet positions simultaneously.
- I had never heard of the "Era of Good Feelings." It was generally meant to reflect a sense of nationalism and unity that persisted at the beginning of Monroe's first term. He sought to eliminate political parties and took steps to build bridges by appointing Federalists to posts in his administration. The idea seemed to hit its pinnacle when in 1820 Monroe was almost unanimously elected (1 vote shy) to a second term. The election was so uninteresting that in Virginia only 4321 of 600,000 eligible voters showed up to the polls.
- His presidency was not all positive. He oversaw the first peacetime depression in the nation's history when the Panic of 1819 hit. It lasted 3 years.
- I had never heard of Monroe's VP before, Daniel Tompkins.
- The White House did not go by that name until it was being rebuilt and repainted following the War of 1812. The Monroes were charged with selecting furniture and ornaments for the refurbished home. However, they were not given a budget to decorate the home which contributed to his debt and almost caused him to cease entertaining at the White House.
- The Louisiana Purchase completely overshadows the Transcontinental Treaty in which Spain ceded Florida to the US and which secured land all the way to the Pacific. John Quincy Adams called it the most important event of his life. It was the culmination of a career of diplomatic work done by Monroe dating back to his days in Europe.
- The Monroe Doctrine is probably what Monroe's presidency is most associated with. Paraphrasing, I take it to be a threat against European countries mostly that they should not further colonize the Americas unless they wished to set off national security alarms in the US. Interestingly the term did not become part of our lexicon until much later than the 1823 speech in which Monroe laid out its principles. 1850 is commonly thought of as when the term was coined.
- In reality, the policy behind the Monroe Doctrine can be credited in large part to JQA who was Secretary of State at the time. In fact, JQA gave Monroe the following text explaining what JQA believed our policy should be toward our borders: "The American continents by the free and independent condition which they have assumed, and maintain, are henceforth not to be considered as subject for future colonization by any European power." Those exact words were later used in the 1823 State of the Union Address.
- Many historians agree that the Monroe Doctrine finally gave the US a national identity apart from Europe.
- I certainly didn't know that Monrovia, Liberia was named for James Monroe. It is the only other capital to be named after a US President (DC being the other).
- Monroe was against slavery and actually attempted to wind it down toward the end of his second term. However, presidential candidates in the Senate blocked his attempt.
- Here's JQA's summary of Monroe's accomplishments in office (pretty solid list/legacy):
- obtained Florida by peaceful means;
- extended the boundary of the nation to the Pacific;
- lowered taxes while reducing the national debt by $60 million;
- constructed a network of coastal defenses to strengthen national security;
- recognized and encouraged the independence of Latin American states (basically the Monroe Doctrine); and
- advanced humanitarian efforts to suppress the slave trade.
- After JQA's inauguration, Monroe stayed at the White House for several weeks. Can you imagine that happening today?
- As with many of his predecessors, Monroe left office in dire financial straits. However, unlike Washington, Jefferson and Madison, it didn't seem to be from over-indulgence. He didn't come from the same means and his official expenses seemed to be greater. He spent a great deal of his retirement petitioning Congress to reimburse him for official expenditures. At one point, he was almost desperate enough to run as JQA's vice president. That would have been weird.
- Probably the strangest fact of all, he became the 3rd of the first 5 presidents to die on July 4.
- "The Chief Magistrate of the Country ought not to be the head of a party, but of the nation itself." - A favorite line of Monroe's
- "Tho' not brilliant, few men were his equals in wisdom, firmness and devotion to the country. He had a wonderful intellectual patience; and could above all men, that I ever knew, when called on to decide an important point, hold the subject immovably fixed under his attention, until he had mastered it in all of its relations. It was mainly to this admirable quality that he owed his highly accurate judgment. I have known many much more rapid in reaching a conclusion, but few with a certainty so unerring." - John C. Calhoun after Monroe's death. I thought this was a good estimation of Monroe. It also reminds me a lot of Washington.
Where was I?
It's been 12 months of checking North American cities off of my bucket list. After hitting Vancouver and Portland last Thanksgiving, I went to Charleston in February with some other guys in what is supposed to be an annual trip somewhere. Hopefully, we can make that tradition stick. The food in Charleston is incredible. The oyster roast was a highlight. It was a little too cold for the beach, which meant fewer tourists, but also no beach. We ended up getting stuck down there for an extra day when our plane couldn't get off the tarmac.
I also made my first two visits to New Orleans. The first trip was for a bachelor party and we spent all of our time in the French Quarter. It's something everyone should do once, but I don't feel like I need to spend any more time on Bourbon Street. The second trip was for Jazz Fest. It was like I was in a different city. All music and food. I'm excited to eventually do a hybrid of the two where we eat well and go to small music shows.
In March, we went to Scottsdale for a wedding. It's another place I hadn't been. The wedding, golf and spring training game were fun, but I don't think I need to head back to the Phoenix area. Our wedding tour continued in Isabela, PR in May. I maintain that PR is underrated.
Firsts resumed in June when I went to Toronto for a bachelor party. It's a cool city that's very easy to get to from DC, and I'd definitely go back. The Skydome could stand to be replaced though.
In July, we spent 5 days at Buffalo Bay. It was great as always. Later that month we spent a weekend at birthing class in anticipation of our new addition due October 8. A week later we went to Oxford, MD as our last official vacation for two. Oxford, Easton and Cambridge are nice, old, quiet towns that are great weekend getaways from DC.
Sparking an Interest:
In addition to Ash Lawn-Highland, Monroe's law office in Fredericksburg is apparently still preserved in some fashion. I don't think I will make an effort to get there unless I'm driving by at some point. Nearby, at Hollywood Cemetery in Richmond, is where Monroe is buried. Again, if I'm in the area, I'll check it out, but won't make a special trip.
So?
Another very thorough, good book. I feel like I keep saying this and it's probably because I knew so little about each subject going into their books, but I think Monroe is another underrated president. He did it all from diplomat to legislator to governor to cabinet member twice to president. That ignores his pre-political life as a war hero and lawyer. Pretty solid resume. I think Ammon presented Monroe's life story very fairly. Monroe seemed to be a popular figure in his time and in my estimation should be a more popular figure today. He did as much as any prior president (with the exception of probably Washington) to unite the young nation and increase its stature in the world.
During the course of reading this book, I was made aware of the website WaitButWhy.com. There's a lot of good, long-form writing on there including this which I found interesting: http://waitbutwhy.com/2014/02/american-presidents-washington-lincoln.html.
As of this date, Donald Trump is the front runner in the Republican primary and Hillary is leading the Dems. It'll be interesting to see what happens over the next 14 months. I have a feeling I won't be reading either of their biographies as part of this project.
5 down, 38+ to go. Up Next: John Quincy Adams: American Visionary
Sunday, February 22, 2015
4. James Madison (In Office 3/4/1809 – 3/4/1817)
Book Title: James Madison: A Biography
Author: Ralph Ketcham
Published: 1990
Length: 760 pages
Start Date: 2/18/14
End Date:10/24/14I finished this book 4 months ago and just haven't gotten around to writing a recap. I just ordered the Monroe book, so I figured I better knock out this post before it arrives. So here's the last 3rd of James Madison: A Biography.
Most Notable (building on the earlier JMad post):
- Around the turn of the 19th century, the Madison family plantation, Montpelier, had become the largest plantation in the country. It was worked by more than 100 slaves.
- Dolley Payne wouldn't have become Dolley Madison, but for the 1793 yellow fever outbreak in Philadelphia that killed her husband and two children. About a year later (9/15/94), JMad and Dolley were married. The couple did not have any kids. Conventional wisdom, based mostly on the fact that Dolley had previously had children, is that JMad was infertile.
- JMad served as Jefferson's Secretary of State.
- The War of 1812, in my opinion, is a very underrated conflict in our nation's history. The bloodiest battle ever on American soil was the Battle of New Orleans in 1815. The battle ended the war, and Andrew Jackson was the hero. In the American Revolution, the British probably didn't take us very seriously and we caught them off guard. In the War of 1812, we absorbed their best and simply out-dueled the British. It established the United States as a legitimate world power. Madison probably doesn't get enough credit for holding the country together at a tough time.
- I mentioned in the first post of this blog that I had previously read A Slave in the White House. It was the book based on the notes from Paul Jennings, the slave that spent so much time very close to JMad, both at Montpelier and in Washington. Somehow he wasn't even mentioned in this book until page 619. I highly recommend A Slave in the White House. It's a very close account of Madison and has a lot of great DC history in it.
- Madison, like 2 of his predecessors, claimed to be anti-slavery but maintained enormous slave populations without which his plantation could not operate. However, he did not believe that freed slaves could be integrated into society. He was a founder of the American Colonization Society which was dedicated to freeing slaves and sending them to Liberia. The US would raise the funding, but selling land in the West. In the end, Madison never even freed his own slaves.
- Though, Jefferson is fairly granted a great deal of credit for the establishment of UVA, Madison played a large role as well. In fact, he served much longer as rector of the University with students in attendance then did TJ.
- At a memorial service for Madison in Orange County, James Barbour - a close friend of both JMad and TJ - stated that Madison's service to the nation had been exceeded only by Washington's. Ketcham described Barbour's sentiment as "the common judgment." John Adams felt similarly, noting in his diary that JMad was "a greater and far more estimable man" than TJ. As mentioned previously, JA was also very close with TJ, therefore these words carry even more weight. Yet, as time has passed, Madison is not nearly as recognized as the other Founding Fathers.
"I will yet hope we may have no more war - [but] if we do alass we are not making ready as we ought to do - Congress trifle away the most precious of their days - days that ought to be devoted to the defiance of their divided country." - Dolly with a quote that could easily describe Congress today.
Where was I?
Since my last post in August, not too much has changed. We've done a lot of traveling. We went to a wedding in St. Louis and an NU football game at Penn State in September. I went to an 18-inning Nationals playoff game that they lost to the Giants. I also went to Austin, TX for the first time to visit my cousin at UT. We spent Halloween weekend in Morris, MN visiting family. Then in November we did a West coast trip to Seattle, Vancouver and Portland. I had been to Seattle a couple of times and always enjoy it. Vancouver and Portland were firsts, and my first trip to our neighbor to the north. Both exceeded expectations, aside from 1 very damp day in Canada. Vancouver's setting is incredible and the food was great. Granville Island was a highlight. Portland is known for its micro-brewing culture. We spent a lot of time biking around to different breweries. It was a lot of fun. A couple of days after Christmas, I went up to NYC for the BC bowl game at Yankee Stadium. A week later, we were at Duke for a BC basketball game. It was my first game at Cameron Indoor Stadium. Though it was a blowout, it was a fun experience. It was also a good excuse to visit friends who had moved to Raleigh about a year earlier. I think we both liked Raleigh, but didn't enjoy having to drive anywhere you wanted to go in the Triangle.
Since finishing Madison, I've read a handful of other books. I finally read To Kill a Mockingbird, just in time for the release of its sequel. I enjoyed the book. Whether I think it deserves the credit it gets, is debatable. It's entertaining enough, but didn't really leave a lasting impression. I also finished Guests of the Ayatollah. It's a pretty unbelievable story and sort of mirrors the Benghazi issue. An embassy in a dangerous place was overrun when some security precautions maybe could have prevented it. The actual Benghazi episode was over pretty quickly, whereas this played out for an interminable 15 months. If the Iran hostage crisis had taken place in the media atmosphere that Benghazi did, it probably would have caused cable news to implode. The most incredible part of the story, I thought, was the completely botched, and eventually aborted rescue mission that killed eight American servicemen. I'll be interested to see how the episode is handled in the Carter and Reagan books. Finally, I read Quiet. It was interesting, but throughout it felt like an introvert trying to rationalize her personality and explain why it's superior to extroverts. I'm quite introverted and enjoyed the support, but I think the tone of the book was a little off and I also think it could have been shorter for what it was. The author is an attorney which probably explains why it wasn't.
Sparking an Interest:
Eventually, I'll make it down to Monticello, Montpelier and Ash Lawn-Highland. I'll probably wait until I'm done with Monroe's bio. Hopefully, I can knock it out by the fall.
When the British burnt down the White House in 1814, French Minister Serurier offered to vacate his townhouse at New York and 18th. The Madisons temporarily took up residence in what is now called the Octagon House. This type of Presidential/DC history really interests me.
So?
The time it took me to get through this book and write a recap is not a reflection on its quality. I thought it was a very thorough, good book. I thought Ketchum was pretty impartial and yet he really shone a light on an under-appreciated leader. Madison definitely could have been a case study in Quiet. He worked tirelessly and successfully behind the scenes and yet is overshadowed by his more extroverted predecessor. For a lot of what TJ was doing, Madison was pulling the strings (see the Louisiana Purchase). I recommend this book, but more so I recommend learning more about our 4th president. An easy criticism is that he flip-flopped between a strong federal government and states rights. However, he seemed to do what he thought was necessary to keep the young nation together. It did not seem self-serving. Therefore, I think it was fair and maybe even selfless. Madison's stock went up through my reading of this book.
4 down, 39+ to go. Up Next: James Monroe: The Quest for National Identity
Monday, August 18, 2014
Madison Midterm Report
So this has slowed to a crawl. I started this book 6 months ago today and just passed the halfway mark. I have a number of excuses. First and foremost, I got married in May. So from February to May, most of my free time was spent on wedding stuff. Then we went to Italy for 2 weeks, which could have provided some good reading time. However, since this book is 800 or so pages and unavailable on Kindle, it is not a great book to travel with, so I left it at home. That leads to excuse #2. With previous books, I would read them on my phone whenever I had some time to kill. This book doesn't allow for that luxury. I've also sprinkled in some other reading the past few months. I'm a big baseball fan and enjoyed Where Nobody Knows Your Name. I'm about 1/3 of the way through Guests of the Ayatollah. I don't remember exactly what inspired me to read it. It may have been a Kindle Deal of the Day at some point. I enjoyed Argo. I don't know. Either way, it's been interesting so far. Finally, To Kill a Mockingbird had been on my list for a long time. I was excited when Harper Lee finally agreed to publish it on Kindle. I started it, but haven't made much of a dent yet. I'll probably restart it when I'm done with Ayatollah. So there are my excuses. Here's what I've learned so far about James Madison.
- JMad (to distinguish from James Monroe) first took the national stage when he was appointed one of Virginia's representatives for the Continental Congress in 1780. At 29, he was the youngest delegate.
- Many people associate Madison with the beginning of what we now know as the Republican party, and thus assume he's a states rights guy. However, early on, Madison was a major proponent of a strong federal government. As the nation became more established and the risks of secession declined, so to did his support of a strong, centralized federal government.
- Madison became a prominent figure, not because he was an inspiring leader along the lines of Washington. Rather, he gained stature based on the strength of his mind. This passage sums up his personality well:
He was thought awkward at formal events, congenial in small groups, and skillful in public councils. He overcame his habitual shyness and reserve only when among people he trusted and when he felt in such command of public issues that he spoke and acted with confidence to support measures he favored. He therefore seldom made a good first impression, seldom overawed a legislative body at his first appearance, and seldom figured in the spicy or dramatic events of which gossip and headlines are made.
- JMad was engaged to be married at age 32, prior to meeting Dolly. However, his 16 year old fiancee broke off the engagement.
- As with TJ and GW, JMad claimed to be against slavery and thought it immoral. However, he owned slaves his entire life. As with biographers of the preceding presidents (absent Adams), I think Ketcham let JMad off the hook a little too easily with regards to slavery. Around 1800, Montpelier had become the largest plantation in the country and was worked by more than 100 slaves.
- JMad was a strong proponent of freedom of religion. Quoting the author, "religious liberty stands out as the one subject upon which Madison took an extreme, absolute, undeviating position throughout his life."
- Generally speaking, I think JMad's role in shaping our new nation is largely undervalued. His vision of the new government included the 3 current branches, one of which being a bicameral legislature, the lower house based on population. He also drafted the "Virginia Plan" which was the basic framework for what became the Constitution.
- Another underrated figure of the time, was a Pennsylvania Delegate named Gouverneur Morris. I had never heard his name before, but apparently he was one of the primary drafters of the Constitution. Madison wrote, "the finish given to the style and arrangement of the Constitution fairly belongs to the pen of Mr. Morris. A better choice could not have been made, as the performance of the task proved."
- A large part of Madison's pre-presidential legacy is his authorship of a great number of the Federalist Papers, along with Alexander Hamilton and John Jay. The series of essays were meant to promote the ratification of the Constitution. Ketcham wrote, "In late October 1787, Hamilton, Jay, and Madison undertook what became the authoritative commentary on the Constitution and the best-known work of political theory ever written in the United States." Though Madison and Hamilton were close political allies at the time, they eventually became bitter rivals.
- Madison was elected as a Congressman in the first national election. He beat out James Monroe. One of his first tasks upon election, was to write GW's first inaugural address.
- My family has spent part of its summer in Madison, Connecticut for over sixty years. I never really associated it with the president, though assumed it was he for which the town was named. The book details JMad's only trip to the area in 1791. I especially enjoyed this passage which takes place right near our vacation home:
The afternoon of June 11, the travelers boarded a sloop in the small fishing village of Guilford for the forty-mile voyage across Long Island Sound to Oysterpond Point on the northeastern tip of Long Island. As the vessel worked its way at high tide past the shoals and rocks of the harbor, the bluffs of Sachem Head disappeared astern, and soon the hulk of Faulkner's Island, grim and desolate in the middle of the sound, loomed to starboard.
- JMad was named an honorary citizen of France for his support of its revolution, though he never even visited the country.
- During GW's second term, the author notes that members of congress paid more attention to their reelections than to proceedings in Congress. Sounds familiar.
- "Men cannot be justly bound by laws in making of which they have no part." - The primary argument for DC statehood.
Monday, February 17, 2014
3. Thomas Jefferson (In Office 3/4/1801 – 3/4/1809)
Book Title: Thomas Jefferson: The Art of Power
Author: John Meacham
Published: 2012
Length: 800 pages
Start Date: 9/10/13
End Date: 1/28/14
Happy Presidents Day. It's been awhile. I hit a little bit of a wall with this one. Part of it was that I knew so much of Jefferson's story from the previous two books so it was hard to stay motivated. Part of it was a busy last few months, which I'll get to later. This could be a long post since it will cover the whole book. Bear with me.
Most Notable:
Happy Presidents Day. It's been awhile. I hit a little bit of a wall with this one. Part of it was that I knew so much of Jefferson's story from the previous two books so it was hard to stay motivated. Part of it was a busy last few months, which I'll get to later. This could be a long post since it will cover the whole book. Bear with me.
Most Notable:
- Whereas the Adams family left a written history of almost everything they did, the record on TJ is a little less complete because upon his wife's death, he destroyed all of their correspondence.
- TJ was a very impressive scholar. He spoke 6 languages: Latin, Greek, French, Italian, Spanish, and English.
- TJ began his political career very early in life. He was elected to the House of Burgesses at 25, wrote the Declaration of Independence at 33, and was elected governor of Virginia at 36. He would later become the first Secretary of State.
- During his 2-year term as governor of VA, TJ moved the capital from Williamsburg to Richmond. Richmond is further inland and therefore provided increased security from the advancing British during the Revolutionary War.
- There had been many false reports of British troops closing in on Richmond. Therefore, when reports surfaced that Benedict Arnold was mounting an attack, TJ was slow to rally a defense. He was able to flee, but the slow reaction led to widespread damage to the capital. In many ways it would be his legacy as governor.
- TJ is remembered as a states' rights guy, but he was a major proponent of a strong national government.
- TJ proposed to free all slaves born after a certain date and to deport them at a certain age. He did not believe that freed slaves could coexist peacefully with their former owners. Later he supported a ban on slavery in any new states.
- I'm sure the majority of people consider TJ to be one of the "framers" of the Constitution. However, he and Adams were in Europe when that document came into existence.
- The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen is France's Declaration of Independence. It was written by Lafayette, someone who spent his formative years as GW's right hand man. TJ had counseled Lafayette in its drafting. I had no idea what an influence the young United States and its citizens had on the French Revolution.
- Sally Hemings was TJ's wife's half sister. It makes TJ's relationship with her even more inappropriate and creepy. Especially considering that on her death bed, TJ;s wife Martha supposedly asked him to never marry again. My guess is that she would have preferred he marry again than carry on a relationship with her enslaved half sister.
- Sally Hemings accompanied TJ's daughter on her trip across the Atlantic to join the diplomat in France. Hemmings, at the time a teen, could have remained in France, a free woman. However, TJ convinced her - pregnant with his child - to return with him to Virginia. In return, TJ promised to free their future offspring - of which there were 4 others to follow - when they reached the age of 21.
- TJ basically lived in the White House alone during his presidency. His family was almost never present.
- One of TJ's biggest initiatives as president was the Lewis & Clark expedition. Some notable facts:
- I did not know that Meriweather Lewis had been TJ's private secretary.
- The budget allocated by Congress was $2,500. The final bill came in about 15 times higher than that.
- The other most notable accomplishment of TJ's presidency was the Louisiana Purchase. Some notable facts:
- It doubled the size of the country.
- The author gives TJ a ton of credit for the acquisition, but in reality France really had no choice but to unload it. "It is not only New Orleans that I will cede, it is the whole colony without any reservation," said Napoleon.
- The purchase price was $15 million or about 3 cents per acre.
- One thing that gets glossed over in the book is Jefferson's role in the removal of Native Americans from their lands. He very aggressively drove them West.
- I think one of the most underrated events in American history is Jefferson's VP, Aaron Burr killing Alexander Hamilton in a duel. Really? That happened? And Burr was never arrested or prosecuted at all?
- Congress had an informal library of 3,000 volumes that was burned by the British in the War of 1812. TJ helped start what is now the Library of Congress by selling 6,487 volumes from his personal library.
- Much in the same way as GW, TJ found himself deep in debt in his retirement. When he died, he owed creditors $1-2 million (in early 21st century terms). He lived beyond his means and his earning potential was severely limited during his years of public service. Sadly this resulted in his entire estate, including Monticello, being sold upon his death.
"Everyone comes into the world with a right to his own person and using it at his own will. This is what is called personal liberty, and is given him by the author of nature, because it is necessary for his own sustenance." -TJ the young attorney representing a mixed race slave seeking his freedom. Like Washington, TJ found himself consistently contradicting himself, believing that slavery was wrong but not able to extricate himself from the practice. Even the sympathetic Meacham said, "Jefferson's capacity to live with contradiction was nothing less than epic."
"I am not a Federalist, because I never submitted the whole system of my opinions to the creed of any party of men whatever in religion, in philosophy, in politics, or in anything else where I was capable of thinking for myself. If I could go to heaven but with a party, I would not go there at all." -TJ describing his bipartisan outlook. I like this. We could use more of it today. People too blindly follow their party wherever it goes without thinking for themselves.
"If our legislature does not heartily push our University we must send our children for education to Kentucky or Cambridge." -TJ discussing his brainchild, UVA. I read this quote to a friend and she smartly pointed out that it seems to ignore his alma mater, William & Mary. There's no apparent explanation.
"It is a charming thing to be loved by everybody and the way to obtain it is, never to quarrel or be angry with anybody." -TJ was fairly vain, caring a lot about what others thought of him. In many ways it made him very inauthentic.
"It is much to be wished that every discouragement should be thrown in the way of men who undertake to trade without capital. The consumers pay for it in the end, and the debts contracted, and bankruptcies occasioned by such commercial adventurers, bring burden and disgrace on our country." -TJ. Where was he during the 2007 liquidity crisis that led to the Great Recession?
"No man will ever bring out of that office the reputation which carries him into it." -TJ on the presidency. Largely remains true.
"I am certainly not an advocate for frequent and untried changes in laws and constitutions. I think moderate imperfections had better be borne with; because, when once known, we accommodate ourselves to them, and find practical means of correcting their ill effects. But I know also that laws and institutions must go hand in hand with the progress of the human mind. As that becomes more developed, more enlightened, as new discoveries are made, new truths disclosed, and manners and opinions change with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also, and keep pace with the times. We might as well require a man to wear still the coat which fitted him when a boy, as civilized society to remain ever under the regimen of their barbarous ancestors." -TJ not sounding like much of a strict constructionist.
"Truth between candid minds can never do harm." -TJ to Adams. I like this quote. Too often people take things personally when another just differs in opinion. I think people need to be more honest with the understanding that not everything is personal.
Fun Fact:
Big few months for me. Maybe that's why it took so long. I got engaged on October 2. The past 4 months have been dominated by wedding planning which has taken away from reading time. It's been exciting, though. Right after the engagement, we went to Chicago and Madison, WI. I had always wanted to go to a football game at Camp Randall, the timing worked out with our trip to Chicago and the game day atmosphere at UW did not disappoint, nor did Madison. It's a great, small city, but go when the weather's nice. We got very lucky.
We've spent a lot of time in the last 4 months training for our second Ragnar race. We had previously done the Tennessee relay and decided we wanted to do the Miami to Key West version. It was a good excuse to go on a tropical vacation in February. The heat was an adjustment, but we had a lot of fun. Key West is great. There's some presidential history there as well, though I decided to skip Harry Truman's vacation home with the hope that I'll be able to make a return trip when I get to his biography.
Since finishing Jefferson, I took a brief hiatus from presidents to read Breaking Night. It was a nice break and an inspirational story. I thought the book could have been a little better done. The first 75% she wasn't even going to school and then in the last 25%, the details go out the window and all of a sudden she's graduated from Harvard. I wish she had spent more time telling us how she got through high school and college. It's worth the quick read, though. It's a good reminder that no matter what obstacles you perceive or actually face, it's never too late to conquer them and write your own future.
Sparking an Interest:
The obvious one here is Monticello. I'm looking forward to taking a trip down there, hopefully this Spring. Although, I'd like to combine it with a trip to Montpelier and I'm not sure I'll be done with the Madison book this Spring. Also, apparently there's a Carter's Mountain right next to Monticello. I'm going to have to check that out when we're there.
So?
This one was a grind. The Adams book was so good that it was a tough act to follow. I thought this book was a little too favorable to Jefferson. It seemed as though Meacham was trying to redeem TJ after all of the Hemings stuff started to pour out and tarnish his reputation. It's undeniably a complete biography and I would recommend it for this type of undertaking. However, of the three books so far, it was probably my least favorite. I went into the book with a pretty negative impression of TJ. This book was very sympathetic, and yet I can't say that I feel much better about our third president. He was unbelievably smart, but he seemed to use his intelligence for self-promotion and manipulation too often.
3 down, 40+ to go. Up Next: James Madison: A Biography
"If our legislature does not heartily push our University we must send our children for education to Kentucky or Cambridge." -TJ discussing his brainchild, UVA. I read this quote to a friend and she smartly pointed out that it seems to ignore his alma mater, William & Mary. There's no apparent explanation.
"It is a charming thing to be loved by everybody and the way to obtain it is, never to quarrel or be angry with anybody." -TJ was fairly vain, caring a lot about what others thought of him. In many ways it made him very inauthentic.
"It is much to be wished that every discouragement should be thrown in the way of men who undertake to trade without capital. The consumers pay for it in the end, and the debts contracted, and bankruptcies occasioned by such commercial adventurers, bring burden and disgrace on our country." -TJ. Where was he during the 2007 liquidity crisis that led to the Great Recession?
"No man will ever bring out of that office the reputation which carries him into it." -TJ on the presidency. Largely remains true.
"I am certainly not an advocate for frequent and untried changes in laws and constitutions. I think moderate imperfections had better be borne with; because, when once known, we accommodate ourselves to them, and find practical means of correcting their ill effects. But I know also that laws and institutions must go hand in hand with the progress of the human mind. As that becomes more developed, more enlightened, as new discoveries are made, new truths disclosed, and manners and opinions change with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also, and keep pace with the times. We might as well require a man to wear still the coat which fitted him when a boy, as civilized society to remain ever under the regimen of their barbarous ancestors." -TJ not sounding like much of a strict constructionist.
"Truth between candid minds can never do harm." -TJ to Adams. I like this quote. Too often people take things personally when another just differs in opinion. I think people need to be more honest with the understanding that not everything is personal.
Fun Fact:
- TJ's dad, Peter, drew the first authoritative map of Virginia.
- TJ's cousin, Peyton Randolph was a big deal too. He was attorney general of VA, Speak of the House of Burgesses, and the first president of the Continental Congress.
- TJ was second cousins with Chief Justice John Marshall, though the two did not get along very well.
Big few months for me. Maybe that's why it took so long. I got engaged on October 2. The past 4 months have been dominated by wedding planning which has taken away from reading time. It's been exciting, though. Right after the engagement, we went to Chicago and Madison, WI. I had always wanted to go to a football game at Camp Randall, the timing worked out with our trip to Chicago and the game day atmosphere at UW did not disappoint, nor did Madison. It's a great, small city, but go when the weather's nice. We got very lucky.
Since finishing Jefferson, I took a brief hiatus from presidents to read Breaking Night. It was a nice break and an inspirational story. I thought the book could have been a little better done. The first 75% she wasn't even going to school and then in the last 25%, the details go out the window and all of a sudden she's graduated from Harvard. I wish she had spent more time telling us how she got through high school and college. It's worth the quick read, though. It's a good reminder that no matter what obstacles you perceive or actually face, it's never too late to conquer them and write your own future.
Sparking an Interest:
The obvious one here is Monticello. I'm looking forward to taking a trip down there, hopefully this Spring. Although, I'd like to combine it with a trip to Montpelier and I'm not sure I'll be done with the Madison book this Spring. Also, apparently there's a Carter's Mountain right next to Monticello. I'm going to have to check that out when we're there.
So?
This one was a grind. The Adams book was so good that it was a tough act to follow. I thought this book was a little too favorable to Jefferson. It seemed as though Meacham was trying to redeem TJ after all of the Hemings stuff started to pour out and tarnish his reputation. It's undeniably a complete biography and I would recommend it for this type of undertaking. However, of the three books so far, it was probably my least favorite. I went into the book with a pretty negative impression of TJ. This book was very sympathetic, and yet I can't say that I feel much better about our third president. He was unbelievably smart, but he seemed to use his intelligence for self-promotion and manipulation too often.
3 down, 40+ to go. Up Next: James Madison: A Biography
Thursday, September 12, 2013
2. John Adams (In Office 3/4/1797 – 3/4/1801)
Book Title: John Adams
Author: David McCullough
Published: 2001
Length: 752 pages
Start Date: 6/28/13
End Date: 9/6/13
Most Notable (building on the midterm report)
- JA cast 31 deciding votes as president of the Senate, always in support of GW and more than by any VP in history.
- I found it interesting that so few pages of the book were dedicated to JA's years as VP given that it was the longest he held any public job. Although, it was appropriate in that he felt so helpless in the role. In many ways, the job hasn't really changed since then.
- When TJ lost the election to JA, he drafted a very nice concession letter to JA. However, he sent it to James Madison first for approval. JA never saw it because Madison thought it was too complimentary and could hurt TJ politically if JA turned out to be a bad president. Madison was ahead of his time. It sounds like a pathetic political move that would happen today.
- JA's legacy is tarnished mostly by his signing of the Alien and Sedition Acts. I remember that phrase from my history classes growing up, but didn't remember what a curtailment of the 1st Amendment they were. It speaks to the atmosphere of unrest and fear at the time.
- JA's presidency was dominated by the debate of whether or not to go to war with France. JA successfully navigated away from war despite criticism from both sides of the aisle. It was his proudest accomplishment as president and probably a very wise decision. Two other accomplishments of which JA was proud was the establishment of the Navy and the Library of Congress, and the appointment of John Marshall as chief justice of the Supreme Court.
- At one point, President Adams and VP Jefferson went over a year without speaking because their relationship had been so contentious and because TJ spent most of his time at Monticello, even while in office.
- I think we can agree that we live in a very polarized political climate. However, when a president dies, you can be sure to see all living presidents - no matter party affiliation - in attendance at the funeral. Surprisingly, TJ did not attend GW's funeral. It comes across as a childish and petty move. It'll be interesting to see how it is portrayed in the TJ book, if at all.
- Alexander Hamilton, portrayed very favorably in the Washington book, took quite a hit in this book. He came across as a self-promoter, meddlesome and manipulative. In the days leading up to the 1801 election, Hamilton published a 54 page pamphlet taking JA apart, sabotaging any chance JA had of winning a second term.
- When TJ ran against JA, it was the first and last time a vice president ran against the president.
- One of JA's greatest disappointments was how his middle son Charles turned out. Charles was a failed businessman that turned to drinking. Eventually, JA renounced him as his son. Charles ended up drinking himself to death. News reached JA, the same day he lost the election. It's hard to imagine that confluence of grief.
- JA never returned to Washington after his presidency.
- TJ's extravagant life and presidency are noted repeatedly. One stat I found galling was his $2,500 per year French wine bill that he amassed while in the White House. Jimmy Carter certainly overcompensated for that.
- JA acknowledged that he was very concerned with his legacy and was clearly hurt by negative reviews of his presidency. Against better judgment, beginning about 8 years after his presidency, he began writing letters of self defense to be published in the Boston Patriot. The letters ran almost weekly for 3 years. In hindsight, he admitted it was excessive and tiresome.
- JA's daughter Nabby got breast cancer and eventually died from it, but not before having a mastectomy. I didn't know breast cancer, let alone a primitive treatment existed back then.
- Despite JA and TJ's bitter political differences, they rekindled a friendship later in life, exchanging over 150 letters between Peacefield and Monticello. It's an amazing window into the late stages of their lives.
- Adams and Jefferson both died on July 4, 1826, the 50th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.
- President JQA did not make it to his father's funeral because word did not reach Washington in time.
"Our obligations to our country never cease but with our lives." -JA on his dedication to public service, an ideal he passed to JQA.
"Griefs upon griefs! Disappointments upon disappointments. What then? This is a gay, merry world notwithstanding." -JA. I thought this quote summed up JA well. He was often bitter and frustrated with things, but throughout, he seemed to loved life. I think it's also a brief, yet apt description of the world we live in. There are many things to get upset about, but in the end, most of us are pretty happy to be alive.
Fun Fact:
McCullough began to write this book as a joint biography of Adams and Jefferson, but then changed his mind. There's a great Q&A at the end of the kindle edition of this book with McCullough where he talks about the process of writing the book. He also discusses the exhaustive letter writing and journal entries by JA and others in the family which account for the most complete written history of any prominent American family.
Where was I?
I started this book in late June. Most of the time since then I've been at home. However, I did spend about 10 days traveling in mid-July. I was able to spend about 5 days in Connecticut with my family. From there, Katie and I flew to Minneapolis to celebrate the marriage of one of my college roommates. Finally, we drove out to Morris, MN, where Katie's brother and family live.
8/28/13 marked the 50th Anniversary of the March on Washington. I headed down to the Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool for the celebration. I didn't see very many of the speakers, but caught a portion of Obama's address. It was a very cool atmosphere and amazing to see the people who had been there in 1963 as well and imagine what a change they've witnessed. It's unbelievable to think that I'm still 60 yrs of presidents away from Lincoln, 150 yrs away from MLK and 200 away from Obama in my reading.
I didn't think that I would be too excited to see Adams landmarks. I still don't think that I'll go too far out of my way to see any. However, if I find myself near Quincy, I would like to stop by Peacefield and the Adams' burial site at United First Parish Church. More feasible and likely is a trip to the Capitol to see John Trumbull's Declaration of Independence.
So?
This book deserves all of the praise and recognition it received when it was first published. It's incredibly well researched, organized and written. I thought the GW book was a little too favorable to GW in many ways. McCullough clearly thinks very highly of JA, but seemed to present things a little more objectively. Having said that, there's a clear preference for JA over TJ. TJ didn't come off too favorably in the GW book and this book certainly reinforced that. Reading this next book should be interesting.
2 down, 41+ to go. Up Next: Thomas Jefferson: The Art of Power
I found this very useful link in looking for the right Jefferson book. I was relieved to see my GW and JA books on there. It's definitely been bookmarked.
Tuesday, September 10, 2013
HBO's John Adams
I thought watching HBO's mini-series based on McCullough's book would be a good, fun way to supplement my reading. As I remember, the show was well-received at the time. Here are my thoughts.
Most of what we know of the people in this book is from letters they wrote and received. As such, it was probably difficult to get those important things from letters into the film. A lot of passages from letters are dealt with by making them dialogue in the film. It wouldn't make for great viewing to translate it word for word. So some artistic license is used throughout. This is somewhat ironic because there is a scene at the end in which JA berates a painter who has taken artistic license in recreating the signing of the Declaration of Independence. Again, ironically, this scene does not occur in the book.
All in all, I wasn't thrilled with the series. I think had I not read the book, I would have enjoyed it more. It just didn't really add much to my reading and was boring at times because I knew what to expect. It was a sort of visual CliffsNotes for the book, the exact thing I would have sought out had I been assigned to read this in high school or college.
I did think that the quality of the acting and overall production was very high. Paul Giamatti and Laura Linney definitely do John and Abigail justice as they were portrayed in the book. The costume and set design was also very believable. All in all, it was well done, but I would not recommend it if you have read the book.
Most of what we know of the people in this book is from letters they wrote and received. As such, it was probably difficult to get those important things from letters into the film. A lot of passages from letters are dealt with by making them dialogue in the film. It wouldn't make for great viewing to translate it word for word. So some artistic license is used throughout. This is somewhat ironic because there is a scene at the end in which JA berates a painter who has taken artistic license in recreating the signing of the Declaration of Independence. Again, ironically, this scene does not occur in the book.
All in all, I wasn't thrilled with the series. I think had I not read the book, I would have enjoyed it more. It just didn't really add much to my reading and was boring at times because I knew what to expect. It was a sort of visual CliffsNotes for the book, the exact thing I would have sought out had I been assigned to read this in high school or college.
I did think that the quality of the acting and overall production was very high. Paul Giamatti and Laura Linney definitely do John and Abigail justice as they were portrayed in the book. The costume and set design was also very believable. All in all, it was well done, but I would not recommend it if you have read the book.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)