Thursday, September 12, 2013

2. John Adams (In Office 3/4/1797 – 3/4/1801)

Book Title: John Adams
Author: David McCullough
Published: 2001
Length: 752 pages
Start Date: 6/28/13
End Date: 9/6/13

Most Notable (building on the midterm report)
  • JA cast 31 deciding votes as president of the Senate, always in support of GW and more than by any VP in history.
  • I found it interesting that so few pages of the book were dedicated to JA's years as VP given that it was the longest he held any public job.  Although, it was appropriate in that he felt so helpless in the role.  In many ways, the job hasn't really changed since then.  
  • When TJ lost the election to JA, he drafted a very nice concession letter to JA.  However, he sent it to James Madison first for approval.  JA never saw it because Madison thought it was too complimentary and could hurt TJ politically if JA turned out to be a bad president.  Madison was ahead of his time.  It sounds like a pathetic political move that would happen today. 
  • JA's legacy is tarnished mostly by his signing of the Alien and Sedition Acts.  I remember that phrase from my history classes growing up, but didn't remember what a curtailment of the 1st Amendment they were.  It speaks to the atmosphere of unrest and fear at the time.  
  • JA's presidency was dominated by the debate of whether or not to go to war with France.  JA successfully navigated away from war despite criticism from both sides of the aisle.  It was his proudest accomplishment as president and probably a very wise decision.  Two other accomplishments of which JA was proud was the establishment of the Navy and the Library of Congress, and the appointment of John Marshall as chief justice of the Supreme Court.  
  • At one point, President Adams and VP Jefferson went over a year without speaking because their relationship had been so contentious and because TJ spent most of his time at Monticello, even while in office.  
  • I think we can agree that we live in a very polarized political climate.  However, when a president dies, you can be sure to see all living presidents - no matter party affiliation - in attendance at the funeral.  Surprisingly, TJ did not attend GW's funeral.  It comes across as a childish and petty move.  It'll be interesting to see how it is portrayed in the TJ book, if at all.  
  • Alexander Hamilton, portrayed very favorably in the Washington book, took quite a hit in this book.  He came across as a self-promoter, meddlesome and manipulative.  In the days leading up to the 1801 election, Hamilton published a 54 page pamphlet taking JA apart, sabotaging any chance JA had of winning a second term.  
  • When TJ ran against JA, it was the first and last time a vice president ran against the president.
  • One of JA's greatest disappointments was how his middle son Charles turned out.  Charles was a failed businessman that turned to drinking.  Eventually, JA renounced him as his son.  Charles ended up drinking himself to death.  News reached JA, the same day he lost the election.  It's hard to imagine that confluence of grief.  
  • JA never returned to Washington after his presidency.  
  • TJ's extravagant life and presidency are noted repeatedly.  One stat I found galling was his $2,500 per year French wine bill that he amassed while in the White House.  Jimmy Carter certainly overcompensated for that.    
  • JA acknowledged that he was very concerned with his legacy and was clearly hurt by negative reviews of his presidency.  Against better judgment, beginning about 8 years after his presidency, he began writing letters of self defense to be published in the Boston Patriot.  The letters ran almost weekly for 3 years.  In hindsight, he admitted it was excessive and tiresome.
  • JA's daughter Nabby got breast cancer and eventually died from it, but not before having a mastectomy.  I didn't know breast cancer, let alone a primitive treatment existed back then.
  • Despite JA and TJ's bitter political differences, they rekindled a friendship later in life, exchanging over 150 letters between Peacefield and Monticello.  It's an amazing window into the late stages of their lives.     
  • Adams and Jefferson both died on July 4, 1826, the 50th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.  
    • President JQA did not make it to his father's funeral because word did not reach Washington in time. 
Quotes:
"Our obligations to our country never cease but with our lives." -JA on his dedication to public service, an ideal he passed to JQA. 

"Griefs upon griefs!  Disappointments upon disappointments.  What then?  This is a gay, merry world notwithstanding." -JA.  I thought this quote summed up JA well.  He was often bitter and frustrated with things, but throughout, he seemed to loved life.  I think it's also a brief, yet apt description of the world we live in.  There are many things to get upset about, but in the end, most of us are pretty happy to be alive.     

Fun Fact:
McCullough began to write this book as a joint biography of Adams and Jefferson, but then changed his mind.  There's a great Q&A at the end of the kindle edition of this book with McCullough where he talks about the process of writing the book.  He also discusses the exhaustive letter writing and journal entries by JA and others in the family which account for the most complete written history of any prominent American family.  

Where was I?
I started this book in late June.  Most of the time since then I've been at home.  However, I did spend about 10 days traveling in mid-July.  I was able to spend about 5 days in Connecticut with my family. From there, Katie and I flew to Minneapolis to celebrate the marriage of one of my college roommates.  Finally, we drove out to Morris, MN, where Katie's brother and family live. 

8/28/13 marked the 50th Anniversary of the March on Washington.  I headed down to the Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool for the celebration.  I didn't see very many of the speakers, but caught a portion of Obama's address.  It was a very cool atmosphere and amazing to see the people who had been there in 1963 as well and imagine what a change they've witnessed.  It's unbelievable to think that I'm still 60 yrs of presidents away from Lincoln, 150 yrs away from MLK and 200 away from Obama in my reading.

Sparking an Interest:
I didn't think that I would be too excited to see Adams landmarks.  I still don't think that I'll go too far out of my way to see any.  However, if I find myself near Quincy, I would like to stop by Peacefield and the Adams' burial site at United First Parish Church.  More feasible and likely is a trip to the Capitol to see John Trumbull's Declaration of Independence.

So?
This book deserves all of the praise and recognition it received when it was first published.  It's incredibly well researched, organized and written.  I thought the GW book was a little too favorable to GW in many ways.  McCullough clearly thinks very highly of JA, but seemed to present things a little more objectively.  Having said that, there's a clear preference for JA over TJ.  TJ didn't come off too favorably in the GW book and this book certainly reinforced that.  Reading this next book should be interesting.  

2 down, 41+ to go.  Up Next: Thomas Jefferson: The Art of Power

I found this very useful link in looking for the right Jefferson book.  I was relieved to see my GW and JA books on there.  It's definitely been bookmarked.

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

HBO's John Adams

I thought watching HBO's mini-series based on McCullough's book would be a good, fun way to supplement my reading.  As I remember, the show was well-received at the time.  Here are my thoughts.

Most of what we know of the people in this book is from letters they wrote and received.  As such, it was probably difficult to get those important things from letters into the film.  A lot of passages from letters are dealt with by making them dialogue in the film.  It wouldn't make for great viewing to translate it word for word.  So some artistic license is used throughout.  This is somewhat ironic because there is a scene at the end in which JA berates a painter who has taken artistic license in recreating the signing of the Declaration of Independence.  Again, ironically, this scene does not occur in the book. 

All in all, I wasn't thrilled with the series.  I think had I not read the book, I would have enjoyed it more.  It just didn't really add much to my reading and was boring at times because I knew what to expect.  It was a sort of visual CliffsNotes for the book, the exact thing I would have sought out had I been assigned to read this in high school or college. 

I did think that the quality of the acting and overall production was very high.  Paul Giamatti and Laura Linney definitely do John and Abigail justice as they were portrayed in the book.  The costume and set design was also very believable.  All in all, it was well done, but I would not recommend it if you have read the book. 

Friday, August 16, 2013

Adams (the first) Midterm Report

I'm almost two thirds through McCullough's John Adams.  I'm already hitting a little bit of a wall.  Part of that I think has to do with the fact that Adams is a less compelling figure than Washington.  Another part probably has to do with the fact that I'm spending half as much time commuting as I was before, and that was when most of my reading got done.  I've also realized that there's going to be a significant amount of repetition and overlapping stories throughout these books.  Each president inevitably has similar experiences and at least some interactions with those that come before and after him.  I'm going to hear a lot of perspectives from the Continental Congresses for instance.  Adams and Jefferson spent a lot of time together and corresponding when they were in Europe at the same time.  I expect to get a little bored during that portion of whatever Jefferson book I choose.   

Having said all that, I still feel good about this project and am still learning a lot.  Here are some of my observations so far.
  • Adams started Harvard at 15.  
  • Back then, there wasn't law school as we know it.  Instead, an aspiring lawyer would apprentice under an experienced attorney for 2 years.  It was something like an unpaid internship.  The contract that Adams signed with his mentor, called for him to pay $100 (I didn't think dollars existed then, but this is the currency quoted in the book) when he could "find it convenient."  Admission to the bar required an interview with another lawyer.   
  • I knew that JA had served as defense attorney for the British soldiers in the Boston Massacre.  The fact that it was such an unpopular and brave move was reinforced.  Also, his defense was so strong that I, like the jury was convinced that the soldiers were acting in self-defense.  
  • Adams was on the five-man committee assigned to draft the Declaration of Independence.  
  • For every sailor in the British navy killed in action or who died of wounds in the era of the American Revolution, seventeen died of disease.
  • Adams spent about 10 years in Europe between France, Holland, and England in official positions with the upstart US government.   
    • His first appointment was to France to negotiate an alliance with the French in our war against the British.   10 year old John Quincy went with him.  His first trip across the Atlantic was a harrowing one.  At one point the ship was struck by lightning, killing one passenger and injuring twenty others.
    • He spent a great deal of time in Holland, mostly trying to secure loans for the colonies.  
    • He was America's first ambassador to Great Britain.  
  • Throughout this book I was reminded of the inefficiency of communicating overseas in the late eighteenth century.  I hadn't thought much about it before since Washington never traveled abroad.  When JA arrived in Paris to negotiate the alliance with the French, he learned that one had already been agreed upon (before he had even left for Paris), but that word just hadn't reached the colonies yet.  Abigail and John's letters to each other were routinely 6 months out of date.  It's hard to imagine how frustrating that must have been.  
  • It wasn't until reading this book that I realized what a revered figure Benjamin Franklin was, especially in Europe where he spent a great deal of his life.  
  • JA wrote Massachusetts' constitution in which he alone decided to refer to MA as a commonwealth rather than a state.  The constitution remains the oldest functioning written constitution in the world. 
  • JA was present and one of three Americans to sign the peace treaty with Britain in Paris on 9/3/1783.
  • It was remarkable how close Adams and Jefferson were while abroad and how bitterly they fought when at home.  From my readings so far, both seem like difficult people to get along with; Adams for his stubbornness and Jefferson for his arrogance and underhandedness. 
  • JQA was initially denied admission to Harvard until he completed several months of tutoring in Greek.  
  • Supposedly the only slave to ever stay under the Adams' roof was Sally Hemings who was traveling with TJ's daughter from Virginia to Paris and stopped in London to stay with J&A.  Hemings would eventually have a fairly notorious place in US history.  
  • TJ and James Madison encouraged Philip Freneau to start the National Gazette, a newspaper that became a mouthpiece for the Republican party and highly critical of Federalists all the way up to GW and JA, but most severely of Alexander Hamilton.  Not coincidentally, the paper was very complimentary of TJ.  Freneau also worked for TJ at the State Department.  Essentially Freneau was a puppet of Madison and TJ.  This was discussed in the GW book as well.  It will be interesting to see what kind of play and spin it gets in the TJ book that I read. 
Favorite Quotes:

We can not insure success, but we can deserve it.
-One of JA's favorites from Joseph Addison's Cato. 

The second day of July 1776 will be the most memorable epocha in the history of America.  I am apt to believe that it will be celebrated by succeeding generations as the great anniversary festival.  It ought to be solemnized with pomp and parade, with shows, games, sports, guns, bells, bonfires, and illuminations from one end of this continent to the other from this time forward forever more. 
-JA in a prescient quote re: Independence Day celebrations.  He just got the date wrong.  

I have sometimes been ready to think that the passion for liberty cannot be equally strong in the breasts of those who have been accustomed to deprive their fellow creatures of theirs.  It always seemed a most iniquitous scheme to me - [to] fight ourselves for what we are daily robbing and plundering from those who have as good a right to freedom as we have. 
-Abigail questioning southerners' commitment to the revolution given their slave ownership.  AA stands in stark contrast to Martha Washington in her intellect and eloquence.   

A memorable change must be made in the system of education and knowledge must become so general as to raise the lower ranks of society nearer to the higher.  The education of a nation instead of being confined to a few schools and universities for the instruction of the few, must become the national care and expense for the formation of the many.
-JA was a huge proponent of public education.  He even tried to write it into MA's constitution, but it ended up on the cutting room floor.  

Thursday, July 11, 2013

Mount Vernon

Having read the GW book, I wanted to head back to Mount Vernon.  I did that this past Saturday.  It felt appropriate to go July 4 weekend and we didn't have much else going on.  We had planned to bike there and stubbornly peddled the 40ish miles round-trip despite the oppressive high 90s heat and suffocating humidity. 

The website recommends allowing at least 2-3 hour to tour the estate.  I figured it could be done more quickly.  I was wrong.  We got there and watched the reasonably informative introduction video that lasted about 25 minutes.  If you plan on going, it's a good way to start things off even if you're relatively familiar with his story.  From there, we started towards the Mansion.  It is a somewhat awe-inspiring moment to first look towards the Mansion across the "bowling green" and imagine the historic figures that have shared that same view.  That feeling didn't fade as we walked around the property.  There are some enormous trees that border the bowling green, some of which date from GW's lifetime. 

There was a decently long line to tour the Mansion, but it would have felt like a wasted trip had we not waited.  One of the first artifacts on the tour is the key to The Bastille that Lafayette had sent to GW in 1790.  It's incredible to think what that key represents and the hands that have touched it.  The most poignant moment of the tour was looking into the Washingtons' bedroom and seeing the bed that GW died in.  Upon his death, Martha moved to a third floor bedroom.  Therefore, we were looking into a room that had remained largely unchanged and uninhabited since his death in 1799.  The tour of the Mansion finished in GW's study, which also remained largely intact, including his bookshelves full of his books.  At this point, according to the website, over 80 million people walk through those same rooms, but it is hard not to feel special being in the same place, looking at the same things as one of the most venerated figures in American - if not world - history.   

From the Mansion, we walked to the tomb where George and Martha were originally buried and where many of their relatives remain, and then to their current tomb.  Typically, I feel uneasy around burial sites and graveyards.  However, there is something different about being in the presence of such prominent figures, whether dead or alive. 

At that point, we had to leave to get back to DC for a dinner reservation.  On the way out, we lamented the fact that we had felt rushed and that there was so much more to see and do, most notably the Reynolds Museum and Education Center and the distillery and gristmill.  I'll definitely be making a return trip to see the rest.  If you haven't been, you should make a point to, but be sure to budget plenty of time.   

Reading Update:
I'm about 10% through John Adams.  At this point, he's at the Second Continental Congress in Philadelphia in 1775.  I hope to have my first Adams post in the next week or so. 

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

1. George Washington (In Office 4/30/1789 – 3/4/1797)


Book Title: Washington: A Life
Author: Ron Chernow
Published: 2010
Length: 948 pages
Start Date: Mid-March 2013
End Date: 6/28/13

The goal here is to not be a watered-down version of each president's Wikipedia page.  This is meant to be a space where I record things that I learned while reading the book, and my experience reading it.  Having said that, I'm sure it will evolve as I go.  I've already realized that doing one post per book is not an ideal strategy.  I made notes while reading, but I may not even remember what some of them mean 3 months later.  It also makes the blog less reader-friendly.  So hopefully, this will be the last time, I try to cram everything into one post.  Going forward, I will try to post once per week as I read.  The weekly posts will be quick snippets of that week's reading.  Then at the end, I will do a summary review.

Top 25 or so:
Here are 22 things (in no particular order) I found interesting in reading this first book.  Some of these I probably should have already known.
  • GW accomplished everything he did without ever having gone to college.  Although, he later received an honorary degree from Harvard.


  • GW never had kids of his own.  This fact may have eased concerns of some skeptics that the presidency would evolve into a monarchy.
  • Martha Washington was married with two children before meeting GW.  Her husband died and thus she was free to remarry.  
  • Martha lived with her first husband and children in what was coincidentally called "The White House."  The White House was the site of GW's marriage to Martha. 
  • GW's first election win was in 1758 when he was elected to the Virginia House of Burgesses.  He never lost another election.
  • GW never traveled to England or anywhere else in Europe.
  • GW liked to hunt bald eagles at Mount Vernon and once killed 5 in one day.
  • Martha's son married a Calvert (famous in Maryland).  Martha did not attend the wedding because she was mourning the death of her daughter.  
  • Martha was also absent from her husband's first inauguration.
  • I didn't know who Richard Montgomery was (other than someone important enough to have a Maryland high school named after him) until I read this book.  Turns out he invaded Canada in 1775.  The idea was that if Canada remained in British hands, it would always represent a threat to the US.  
  • Benedict Arnold was a highly-regarded, loyal, American officer before conspiring to sabotage West Point and hand it over to the British.
  • George Mason wrote the first draft of the Declaration of Independence.  Later, he was so opposed to the Constitution, that it ruined his friendship with GW.
  • Though we celebrate the anniversary of the Declaration of Independence on July 4, GW did not see the document until July 8. 
  • GW created what came to be known as the Purple Heart to recognize "unusual gallantry" or "extraordinary fidelity and essential service."  Recipients would pin a purple, heart-shaped cloth on their shirt. 
  • GW had only one of his own teeth left by the time of his first inauguration.  Most of the teeth in his mouth were bought from slaves and turned into dentures anchored to his one tooth.  
  • GW's first appointments to SCOTUS were six justices who were all approved by the Senate within 48 hours.   
  • GW won both presidential elections with unanimous votes in the Electoral College.
  • During the Whiskey Rebellion, GW became the first and only president to supervise troops in a combat situation.
  • GW's presidential salary was $25,000/year.
  • GW struggled with his finances throughout his life and had to borrow money to attend his own inauguration in 1789.  
  • In 1793, Yellow Fever killed 10% of Philadelphia's residents.  The city's citizenry remains bitter to this day.
  • GW died at the age of 67.  The book has 67 chapters.  Coincidence, appropriate tribute or cheesy.
Favorite Quote: 
The Constitution can only lay the foundation - the community at large must raise the edifice.

Where was I?
I went on two pretty significant trips while reading this book.  The first was to Boston for my dad's 46th consecutive Boston Marathon.  Unfortunately, two Chechen brothers had other plans for that day.  The second trip was my first to London.  At that point, the book was right in the middle of the Revolutionary War, which left me fairly bitter towards Britain.  I got over it and can say that GW missed out by never making it over there. 

Sparking an Interest:
I anticipate that reading these books will pique my interest in certain aspects of the presidents' lives and certain places in our country.  For instance, while reading this book, I had a trip planned to Philadelphia and thought it would be interesting to see the two houses that GW lived in there as president.  I was surprised and disappointed to learn that neither has been preserved.  I've been to Mount Vernon once, but plan to go there again soon with a much greater appreciation for its place in history.  I would also like to learn more about the Free Masons.  Alternatively, though his time leading the Revolutionary War is what made him famous, historic battlefields don't do much for me, so I don't imagine I'll make a special effort to see them after reading these books.  I would, however, like to visit Fort Washington in Manhattan.  

So?
I would definitely recommend this book.  It seemed comprehensive without getting too bogged down in detail.  My one criticism is that it seemed as though Chernow liked GW a little too much and gave him the benefit of the doubt too often.  For instance, he praised GW's distaste for slavery, despite the fact that at GW's death, he still oversaw over 300 slaves.  GW had many, very credible detractors on a number of issues.  Chief among them was our third president, Thomas Jefferson.  Yet, Chernow's bias led me to side with GW very easily.  We'll see how I feel after getting through TJ's bio (if you've read a good one, leave it in the comments).  

1 down.  42+ to go.  Next up: John Adams.

Friday, May 17, 2013

Introduction

A few years ago, I had the idea that I wanted to read a substantial biography on every U.S. president in order.  I didn't enjoy history much growing up and feel as though it's a gap in my knowledge base.  Additionally, I've enjoyed reading memoirs and biographies of historical figures, especially those that take place in Washington, DC.  I figured it would be a project that I would enjoy and one that would give me a great U.S. history lesson.  However, it was and remains a daunting undertaking.  I put it off as I read other books on my list.  Some of those books were, The Siege of Washington, A Slave in the White House, What it Takes, The Presidents Club, and Losers.  One quickly learns that it takes a special type of person to think they could be president and that there's an even more exclusive group that is up to the task.  They make for fascinating subjects and have incredible stories to tell.  The project remained in the back of my mind, but I just didn't - and still don't - know if I could realistically achieve it.

I make a habit of checking Amazon's Kindle Daily Deal.  Non-fiction books are rare, but I think I found most of the above books there.  December 26, 2012, the Daily Deal was Washington: A Life.  I downloaded it with the idea of finally beginning the project.  I still wasn't ready.  I really didn't want to start something and not see it through, so I had to make sure I was ready to commit to it.  Some time in March of 2013 I talked the idea over with a couple of friends.  Their initial reactions were that it would take forever (we estimated 15-20 years), it would come at the expense of reading a lot of other great stuff (acknowledged), and that if I was going to do it, I would have to document it somehow (a blog was the obvious choice).

Another challenge that was discussed was how I am going to select which biography to read.  I tend to shy away from autobiographies, so those are out.  I want to read books that are well-regarded and thorough, but not endlessly long (any book with multiple volumes is out).  There have been some iconic biographies written by great authors during my life.  McCullough's John Adams springs to mind.  Those will be easier choices.  For the others, I'll rely mostly on internet research and recommendations (please leave any in the comments section).    

Having talked through some logistics, I was re-energized by the idea and ready to go.  Since beginning the first book, the framework for the blog has started to materialize and evolve in my head.  My instinct is to do some vital stats on the book (title, author, date, length), a summary of my experience reading it (how quickly it went and whether I recommend it), a critique, and a few interesting facts that I learned.  I hope to keep it pretty light.  The blog is meant to serve as a journal for myself and hopefully a resource for others that have done or want to do what I'm attempting.

The title is in reference to the 43 men that have currently served as president (43 was taken and forty three was too long).  Hopefully, I get this done before the count is too much higher.  The goal is three per year, ideally with some other books sprinkled in.  Here we go.