5. James Monroe (In Office 3/4/1817 – 3/4/1825)
Book Title: James Monroe: The Quest for National Identity
Author: Harry Ammon
Published:1971
Length: 706
Start Date: 2/25/15
End Date: 8/1/15So the write up took only 2 month. Anyway, 5 down.
Most Notable:
- He entered William & Mary at 16, but spent only 2 years there before enlisting to fight in the Revolutionary War. After the war, Monroe decided that he wanted to get into politics. His friend and mentor, Thomas Jefferson suggested that he study the law and become a lawyer in order to further his political career. As such, Monroe studied law under TJ, then the governor of Virginia.
- While fighting in the war, he was nearly killed. He was shot in the shoulder, severing an artery that a local doctor was quickly able to seal. Otherwise, he likely would have bled out. He was nursed back to health for 3 months at a stranger's home nearby.
- He won his first election in 1782 when he was elected to the Virginia House of Delegates.
- In 1783, the Virginia state legislature nominated him to represent the state in Congress. He served for the next 3 years.
- When the Constitution was being circulated for ratification, Monroe argued strenuously against the electoral college. He thought it violated the most basic concept of a republican government (1 person, 1 vote). He also thought it would render the President subservient to state interests. I wish people had listened to him. The electoral college makes no sense.
- Madison and Monroe were very close. Yet in 1788 Monroe decided to run against Madison for Congress. It was a very congenial campaign on both sides. Madison cruised to victory and the two resumed their friendship without injury.
- In 1790, at the age of just 32, Monroe was elected to the Senate.
- In 1794, President Washington appointed Monroe Minister to France. Monroe left the Senate for Europe, but was recalled just 2 years later because Washington felt as though Monroe was letting partisanship impact his diplomacy.
- In 1799, Monroe was elected Governor of Virginia. At the time, the Governor was elected by the legislator every year. Monroe served the maximum 3 consecutive terms and earned $9,999 over those 3 years.
- In order to make up for 3 years of modest income, he planned to settle in Richmond and practice law following his third term. However, President Jefferson sent Monroe to France to negotiate the purchase of New Orleans, which eventually ended up being the Louisiana Purchase.
- He stayed in Europe as the Minister to the Court of St. James in London until 1807. While there, he tried to extend the Jay Treaty, which was set to expire 10 years after it was signed. Monroe thought it positioned the US well, but TJ and Secretary of State Madison, both Francophiles, refused to submit it to the Senate for approval. The failure to reach an agreement led in part to the War of 1812. Monroe was somewhat offended by the disagreement with his friends and their relationships were strained for a couple of years.
- In 1811 Monroe was again elected Governor of Virginia, but served only 4 months before President Madison appointed him Secretary of State.
- One thing that's changed over time is that Republicans were very against military spending. The author uses the term "anti-militaristic principles." The author notes that Republicans were horrified that $9 million of the $25.5 budget was spent on defense. That's hard to picture today. Monroe was more inline with current Republicans. He thought it was important to threaten military action in negotiations.
- At the beginning of the War of 1812, Madison appointed Monroe acting Secretary of War. He served there for only 10 weeks to organize the war efforts and then returned to the State Department. However, his replacement at the War Department left and Monroe then became the first person to hold 2 cabinet positions simultaneously.
- I had never heard of the "Era of Good Feelings." It was generally meant to reflect a sense of nationalism and unity that persisted at the beginning of Monroe's first term. He sought to eliminate political parties and took steps to build bridges by appointing Federalists to posts in his administration. The idea seemed to hit its pinnacle when in 1820 Monroe was almost unanimously elected (1 vote shy) to a second term. The election was so uninteresting that in Virginia only 4321 of 600,000 eligible voters showed up to the polls.
- His presidency was not all positive. He oversaw the first peacetime depression in the nation's history when the Panic of 1819 hit. It lasted 3 years.
- I had never heard of Monroe's VP before, Daniel Tompkins.
- The White House did not go by that name until it was being rebuilt and repainted following the War of 1812. The Monroes were charged with selecting furniture and ornaments for the refurbished home. However, they were not given a budget to decorate the home which contributed to his debt and almost caused him to cease entertaining at the White House.
- The Louisiana Purchase completely overshadows the Transcontinental Treaty in which Spain ceded Florida to the US and which secured land all the way to the Pacific. John Quincy Adams called it the most important event of his life. It was the culmination of a career of diplomatic work done by Monroe dating back to his days in Europe.
- The Monroe Doctrine is probably what Monroe's presidency is most associated with. Paraphrasing, I take it to be a threat against European countries mostly that they should not further colonize the Americas unless they wished to set off national security alarms in the US. Interestingly the term did not become part of our lexicon until much later than the 1823 speech in which Monroe laid out its principles. 1850 is commonly thought of as when the term was coined.
- In reality, the policy behind the Monroe Doctrine can be credited in large part to JQA who was Secretary of State at the time. In fact, JQA gave Monroe the following text explaining what JQA believed our policy should be toward our borders: "The American continents by the free and independent condition which they have assumed, and maintain, are henceforth not to be considered as subject for future colonization by any European power." Those exact words were later used in the 1823 State of the Union Address.
- Many historians agree that the Monroe Doctrine finally gave the US a national identity apart from Europe.
- I certainly didn't know that Monrovia, Liberia was named for James Monroe. It is the only other capital to be named after a US President (DC being the other).
- Monroe was against slavery and actually attempted to wind it down toward the end of his second term. However, presidential candidates in the Senate blocked his attempt.
- Here's JQA's summary of Monroe's accomplishments in office (pretty solid list/legacy):
- obtained Florida by peaceful means;
- extended the boundary of the nation to the Pacific;
- lowered taxes while reducing the national debt by $60 million;
- constructed a network of coastal defenses to strengthen national security;
- recognized and encouraged the independence of Latin American states (basically the Monroe Doctrine); and
- advanced humanitarian efforts to suppress the slave trade.
- After JQA's inauguration, Monroe stayed at the White House for several weeks. Can you imagine that happening today?
- As with many of his predecessors, Monroe left office in dire financial straits. However, unlike Washington, Jefferson and Madison, it didn't seem to be from over-indulgence. He didn't come from the same means and his official expenses seemed to be greater. He spent a great deal of his retirement petitioning Congress to reimburse him for official expenditures. At one point, he was almost desperate enough to run as JQA's vice president. That would have been weird.
- Probably the strangest fact of all, he became the 3rd of the first 5 presidents to die on July 4.
- "The Chief Magistrate of the Country ought not to be the head of a party, but of the nation itself." - A favorite line of Monroe's
- "Tho' not brilliant, few men were his equals in wisdom, firmness and devotion to the country. He had a wonderful intellectual patience; and could above all men, that I ever knew, when called on to decide an important point, hold the subject immovably fixed under his attention, until he had mastered it in all of its relations. It was mainly to this admirable quality that he owed his highly accurate judgment. I have known many much more rapid in reaching a conclusion, but few with a certainty so unerring." - John C. Calhoun after Monroe's death. I thought this was a good estimation of Monroe. It also reminds me a lot of Washington.
Where was I?
It's been 12 months of checking North American cities off of my bucket list. After hitting Vancouver and Portland last Thanksgiving, I went to Charleston in February with some other guys in what is supposed to be an annual trip somewhere. Hopefully, we can make that tradition stick. The food in Charleston is incredible. The oyster roast was a highlight. It was a little too cold for the beach, which meant fewer tourists, but also no beach. We ended up getting stuck down there for an extra day when our plane couldn't get off the tarmac.
I also made my first two visits to New Orleans. The first trip was for a bachelor party and we spent all of our time in the French Quarter. It's something everyone should do once, but I don't feel like I need to spend any more time on Bourbon Street. The second trip was for Jazz Fest. It was like I was in a different city. All music and food. I'm excited to eventually do a hybrid of the two where we eat well and go to small music shows.
In March, we went to Scottsdale for a wedding. It's another place I hadn't been. The wedding, golf and spring training game were fun, but I don't think I need to head back to the Phoenix area. Our wedding tour continued in Isabela, PR in May. I maintain that PR is underrated.
Firsts resumed in June when I went to Toronto for a bachelor party. It's a cool city that's very easy to get to from DC, and I'd definitely go back. The Skydome could stand to be replaced though.
In July, we spent 5 days at Buffalo Bay. It was great as always. Later that month we spent a weekend at birthing class in anticipation of our new addition due October 8. A week later we went to Oxford, MD as our last official vacation for two. Oxford, Easton and Cambridge are nice, old, quiet towns that are great weekend getaways from DC.
Sparking an Interest:
In addition to Ash Lawn-Highland, Monroe's law office in Fredericksburg is apparently still preserved in some fashion. I don't think I will make an effort to get there unless I'm driving by at some point. Nearby, at Hollywood Cemetery in Richmond, is where Monroe is buried. Again, if I'm in the area, I'll check it out, but won't make a special trip.
So?
Another very thorough, good book. I feel like I keep saying this and it's probably because I knew so little about each subject going into their books, but I think Monroe is another underrated president. He did it all from diplomat to legislator to governor to cabinet member twice to president. That ignores his pre-political life as a war hero and lawyer. Pretty solid resume. I think Ammon presented Monroe's life story very fairly. Monroe seemed to be a popular figure in his time and in my estimation should be a more popular figure today. He did as much as any prior president (with the exception of probably Washington) to unite the young nation and increase its stature in the world.
During the course of reading this book, I was made aware of the website WaitButWhy.com. There's a lot of good, long-form writing on there including this which I found interesting: http://waitbutwhy.com/2014/02/american-presidents-washington-lincoln.html.
As of this date, Donald Trump is the front runner in the Republican primary and Hillary is leading the Dems. It'll be interesting to see what happens over the next 14 months. I have a feeling I won't be reading either of their biographies as part of this project.
5 down, 38+ to go. Up Next: John Quincy Adams: American Visionary