I thought watching HBO's mini-series based on McCullough's book would be a good, fun way to supplement my reading. As I remember, the show was well-received at the time. Here are my thoughts.
Most of what we know of the people in this book is
from letters they wrote and received. As such, it was probably
difficult to get those important things from letters into the film. A
lot of passages from letters are dealt with by making them dialogue in
the film. It wouldn't make for great viewing to translate it word for
word. So some artistic license is used throughout. This is somewhat
ironic because there is a scene at the end in which JA berates a painter
who has taken artistic license in recreating the signing of the
Declaration of Independence. Again, ironically, this scene does not occur in the
book.
All in all, I wasn't thrilled with the series. I think had I not read the book, I would have enjoyed it more. It just didn't really add much to my reading and was boring at times because I knew what to expect. It was a sort of visual CliffsNotes for the book, the exact thing I would have sought out had I been assigned to read this in high school or college.
I did think that the quality of the acting and overall production was very high. Paul Giamatti and Laura Linney definitely do John and Abigail justice as they were portrayed in the book. The costume and set design was also very believable. All in all, it was well done, but I would not recommend it if you have read the book.
No comments:
Post a Comment