Sunday, February 22, 2015

4. James Madison (In Office 3/4/1809 – 3/4/1817)

Author: Ralph Ketcham
Published: 1990
Length: 760 pages
Start Date: 2/18/14
End Date:10/24/14

I finished this book 4 months ago and just haven't gotten around to writing a recap.  I just ordered the Monroe book, so I figured I better knock out this post before it arrives.  So here's the last 3rd of James Madison: A Biography.   

Most Notable (building on the earlier JMad post):

  • Around the turn of the 19th century, the Madison family plantation, Montpelier, had become the largest plantation in the country.  It was worked by more than 100 slaves.
  • Dolley Payne wouldn't have become Dolley Madison, but for the 1793 yellow fever outbreak in Philadelphia that killed her husband and two children.  About a year later (9/15/94), JMad and Dolley were married.  The couple did not have any kids.  Conventional wisdom, based mostly on the fact that Dolley had previously had children, is that JMad was infertile.
  • JMad served as Jefferson's Secretary of State.
  • The War of 1812, in my opinion, is a very underrated conflict in our nation's history.  The bloodiest battle ever on American soil was the Battle of New Orleans in 1815.  The battle ended the war, and Andrew Jackson was the hero.  In the American Revolution, the British probably didn't take us very seriously and we caught them off guard.  In the War of 1812, we absorbed their best and simply out-dueled the British.  It established the United States as a legitimate world power.  Madison probably doesn't get enough credit for holding the country together at a tough time. 
  • I mentioned in the first post of this blog that I had previously read A Slave in the White House.  It was the book based on the notes from Paul Jennings, the slave that spent so much time very close to JMad, both at Montpelier and in Washington.  Somehow he wasn't even mentioned in this book until page 619.  I highly recommend A Slave in the White House.  It's a very close account of Madison and has a lot of great DC history in it.  
  • Madison, like 2 of his predecessors, claimed to be anti-slavery but maintained enormous slave populations without which his plantation could not operate.  However, he did not believe that freed slaves could be integrated into society.  He was a founder of the American Colonization Society which was dedicated to freeing slaves and sending them to Liberia.  The US would raise the funding, but selling land in the West.  In the end, Madison never even freed his own slaves. 
  • Though, Jefferson is fairly granted a great deal of credit for the establishment of UVA, Madison played a large role as well.  In fact, he served much longer as rector of the University with students in attendance then did TJ.  
  • At a memorial service for Madison in Orange County, James Barbour - a close friend of both JMad and TJ - stated that Madison's service to the nation had been exceeded only by Washington's.  Ketcham described Barbour's sentiment as "the common judgment."  John Adams felt similarly, noting in his diary that JMad was "a greater and far more estimable man" than TJ.  As mentioned previously, JA was also very close with TJ, therefore these words carry even more weight.  Yet, as time has passed, Madison is not nearly as recognized as the other Founding Fathers. 
Quotes:

"I will yet hope we may have no more war - [but] if we do alass we are not making ready as we ought to do - Congress trifle away the most precious of their days - days that ought to be devoted to the defiance of their divided country." - Dolly with a quote that could easily describe Congress today.   
 
Where was I?
Since my last post in August, not too much has changed.  We've done a lot of traveling.  We went to a wedding in St. Louis and an NU football game at Penn State in September.  I went to an 18-inning Nationals playoff game that they lost to the Giants.  I also went to Austin, TX for the first time to visit my cousin at UT.  We spent Halloween weekend in Morris, MN visiting family.  Then in November we did a West coast trip to Seattle, Vancouver and Portland.  I had been to Seattle a couple of times and always enjoy it.  Vancouver and Portland were firsts, and my first trip to our neighbor to the north.  Both exceeded expectations, aside from 1 very damp day in Canada.  Vancouver's setting is incredible and the food was great.  Granville Island was a highlight.  Portland is known for its micro-brewing culture.  We spent a lot of time biking around to different breweries.  It was a lot of fun.  A couple of days after Christmas, I went up to NYC for the BC bowl game at Yankee Stadium.  A week later, we were at Duke for a BC basketball game.  It was my first game at Cameron Indoor Stadium.  Though it was a blowout, it was a fun experience.  It was also a good excuse to visit friends who had moved to Raleigh about a year earlier.  I think we both liked Raleigh, but didn't enjoy having to drive anywhere you wanted to go in the Triangle.   

Since finishing Madison, I've read a handful of other books.  I finally read To Kill a Mockingbird, just in time for the release of its sequel.  I enjoyed the book.  Whether I think it deserves the credit it gets, is debatable.  It's entertaining enough, but didn't really leave a lasting impression.  I also finished Guests of the Ayatollah.  It's a pretty unbelievable story and sort of mirrors the Benghazi issue.  An embassy in a dangerous place was overrun when some security precautions maybe could have prevented it.  The actual Benghazi episode was over pretty quickly, whereas this played out for an interminable 15 months.  If the Iran hostage crisis had taken place in the media atmosphere that Benghazi did, it probably would have caused cable news to implode.  The most incredible part of the story, I thought, was the completely botched, and eventually aborted rescue mission that killed eight American servicemen.  I'll be interested to see how the episode is handled in the Carter and Reagan books.  Finally, I read Quiet.  It was interesting, but throughout it felt like an introvert trying to rationalize her personality and explain why it's superior to extroverts.  I'm quite introverted and enjoyed the support, but I think the tone of the book was a little off and I also think it could have been shorter for what it was.  The author is an attorney which probably explains why it wasn't.  

Sparking an Interest:

Eventually, I'll make it down to Monticello, Montpelier and Ash Lawn-Highland.  I'll probably wait until I'm done with Monroe's bio.  Hopefully, I can knock it out by the fall.   

When the British burnt down the White House in 1814, French Minister Serurier offered to vacate his townhouse at New York and 18th.  The Madisons temporarily took up residence in what is now called the Octagon House.  This type of Presidential/DC history really interests me.    


So?

The time it took me to get through this book and write a recap is not a reflection on its quality.  I thought it was a very thorough, good book.  I thought Ketchum was pretty impartial and yet he really shone a light on an under-appreciated leader.  Madison definitely could have been a case study in Quiet.  He worked tirelessly and successfully behind the scenes and yet is overshadowed by his more extroverted predecessor.  For a lot of what TJ was doing, Madison was pulling the strings (see the Louisiana Purchase).   I recommend this book, but more so I recommend learning more about our 4th president.  An easy criticism is that he flip-flopped between a strong federal government and states rights.  However, he seemed to do what he thought was necessary to keep the young nation together.  It did not seem self-serving.  Therefore, I think it was fair and maybe even selfless.  Madison's stock went up through my reading of this book.    

4 down, 39+ to go.  Up Next: James Monroe: The Quest for National Identity

No comments:

Post a Comment